Friday, 13 December 2019

A glimpse of The Dragon!

Though I have always heard the Chinese dragon and Indian elephant as common terms used in diplomacy and trade but to my surprise, during my recent visit to China, I found the Beijing zoo full of elephants (both real and artificial structures) and every souvenir shop selling elephant along with dragon!
Elephant structures at Beijing Zoo

I recently visited China to attend a Seminar on Intellectual property and development, organised by the Ministry of Commerce of China. Some 25 delegates from 12 different countries attended the workshop which briefed about the changes made by China in its domestic legislations with respect to copyrights, trademarks, patents etc. to make them more stringent in the wake of allegations of intellectual property theft by Chinese companies. Interestingly, the progress was not just in terms of legislation but also technological advancements in the field of Intellectual property. China has opened special IP courts in three big cities of Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou. These courts are equipped to handle the appeals in IP cases online. The appellant need not be physically present in the court and the final judgement is sent via a soft copy through email!

The Intellectual property court of Supreme People's Court of China

The technological advancement in China stretches beyond the field of Intellectual property. Their E-commerce companies like Huawei and Alibaba (the two we visited) were using cutting-edge technological know-how. Their campuses in Beijing were highly smart and tech efficient. The number of verticals in which they are expanding is increasing at a rapid pace. Many Indian companies like Infosys, Tech Mahindra are partnering with Huawei. 



The sheer magnanimity of the campuses!

Another peculiar thing about the Chinese infrastructure was it's grandiosity. No wonder that Tiananmen square is the largest public square in the world. It has the capacity of catering to 1 million people at a given time. Doubting this figure, we asked our Chinese guide, how can this be true! He hilariously remarked that the Chinese are slim!! Which brings me to their cuisine and eating habits. Most of their regular diet is composed of beef (A HUGE part), fish- boiled in a soup ou served with sauce, boiled vegetables and sticky rice. They have soya milk and wheat based baked bread (very different from Indian or continental bread) in the breakfast. Breakfast is usually served at 7:30 in the morning, lunch at 12 and dinner starts from 6 and ends at 7:30 in the evening. On my first day in Beijing, I reached Beijing after 18 hours of travel from Geneva at nearly 5:30 in the evening. We were told to be ready for the dinner after half an hour. Having completed my dinner by 6:30pm and due to jet lag, I couldn't stop the hunger from overpowering my sleep at 3am in the night! 

Coming back to the grandiosity, the streets are so wide with almost 6-8 lanes and separate cycling and pedestrian tracks. It's quite ironic that despite such infrastructure, the traffic in Beijing takes a toll on you, specially during the rush hours in evening! And the subway is exactly like the Delhi metro. But what is different, is the state of public transport- highly equipped double-decker buses with dustbins, very punctual and efficient transport system and not to forget- the bullet trains connecting entire East China with a speed of 350 km/hour. The organisers took us to the Great Wall of China and the forbidden City on the weekend. The courts and palaces of the forbidden City were seeming like limitless, never-ending pathways! We climbed up to the highest Fortress no. 12 at the Great Wall. It was a great adventure.

Typical wooden architecture with colourful carvings



The Tiananmen square and the Forbidden City.





The happiness and sense of achievement after reaching the highest point!

The Great Wall- one of the seven wonders of the world!

Along with Beijing, we visited the Hebei province of China which was some 4-5 hours of travel by road. There we found that not all the provinces of China are that tech advanced as Beijing. Hebei was a province famous for the intangible cultural heritage of paper-cutting. We visited a paper-cutting village and learnt this beautiful art. Each of us was given a drawing of an animal based on our birth year. Chinese have this traditional system of linking every year with an animal. Amusing enough that I was given a mouse! And then with the specialised needles, we cut the paper. And the end result was surprisingly so creative! 
Mona-Lisa created by the art of paper-cutting!



                                     Jaw-dropping paper cut art work by Chinese artists!


And the hidden artist in me came out in the form of this mouse!

The paper cut artworks are one of the popular souvenirs from China. Chinese protect their traditional knowledge and folklore, like it is protected in India and other Asian countries with rich cultural heritage.

Some general impressions about the Chinese- 
  • Ultra rich (Using products of high-ended brands like Lancome, Chanel)
  • Spirit of sharing, kind-hearted 
  • Very punctual 
  • Great sense of responsibility
  • Terrific players (Games like badminton, TT etc)
  • No comparison with India in hospitality- India is a unique country with the concept of "Atithi Devoh Bhavah". I think that was missing in China- the way our companies and public institutions greet the foreigners with tea/coffee, snacks and souvenirs!

Beijing is also a very dry, utterly cold place with very strong Siberian winds. People are very cultured. They keep the public spaces clean and are usually disciplined. 
Although it hasn't really snowed in Geneva this year, but it was rare and astonishing to find a thick layer of snow in Beijing in end November. So rare that on a Saturday morning, Chinese queued up in thousands to get entry into the Jingshan park which had turned into Switzerland under the snow!





Summer palace and Jingshan park covered with thick layers of ice and the frozen lakes.

I also learnt that Chinese people are extremely talented in creating the beauty artificially to attract tourists. The Jingshan park is built around a mountain, which is created by depositing mud from an adjacent moat. The streets in Beijing are very lively and full of people at all times. They appear much like European or American streets. Very tidy, neat and clean, pedestrian-friendly, well lit-up. Even in the off-season of tourism, the domestic tourism in Beijing is on a very large scale. Foreign tourists also flock in huge numbers.

Temple of heaven in Beijing



                                                               Very lively Sanlitun Street



Chinese have their own versions of Palika and Sarojini bazaars of Delhi- the Pearl market and the silk market. And bargaining works at an even higher scale than Delhi! Usually the actual price of a product is 70-80% less than the quoted price.

And last but not the least were the cutest wildlife creatures- Giant pandas at the Beijing Zoo! Beijing aquarium is a world-class aquarium with modern Dolphin shows.











All in all, China was a thrilling and enriching experience!

Monday, 1 April 2019

Book review- Delusional Politics by Hardeep Singh Puri

Writing after a long time and  about the book which I received the firsthand copy from the author himself on 26th of January this year.

About Hardeep Puri Sir,  there's always an inspiration to draw from his four-decade long career in diplomacy. He was a pioneer of multilateral diplomacy having served as a diplomat at Indian Mission in Geneva where I'm presently serving and also as Indian representative to UN in New York. Hia previous book which I read last year- Perilous interventions was very aptly descriptive of the misconceived interventionism by West in Iraq, Libya and Syria and also by Saudi Arabia  and Iran in Yemen and Russian intervention in Ukraine, in almost all cases, achieving the geostrategic objectives was the primary goal of invention often made under the garb of humanitarian crisis and for peace. It provides an account into how the UN, as the harbinger of international peace and security, failed to prevent the spread of insecurity among the nations.

In his latest book, Delusional politics, Puri Sir delves into the  politics of delusion practiced by the political leadership without thinking about the far reaching consequences of their act. An ill-conceived thought of holding a referendum on Brexit came in the mind of David Cameron with his political motive to strengthen his standing in the Conservative party. How this decision is now ruining and threatening the British. He also describes the policy making under Trump as being Delusional.

Without delving into the political aspects of the book, here is the summary of the chapters on terrorism and trade-

  1. Politics of terror: Abject poverty, religion and lack of education are not the only forces behind terrorism. It's actually based on constellation of fault lines. Imbalances caused by exclusionary, unaccountable and ideologically based governance; inequitable distribution of resources, deft use of internet and social media in the era of new and emerging geopolitical power rivalries are some of the causes.                                  
  2. Lack of a global definition of terrorism within the multilateral system under UN- Major objections on:
State use of armed forces against civilians and right to resistance of the people under foreign occupation.
"It's inconceivable that any terror outfit can outgrow its modest beginning without external assistance"- by a group of individuals/another state/entities.

Online radicalism- when finally the West has decided to shed its delusions on terrorism due to lone-wolf attacks on its soil.

How's ISIS different from JeM or Jamaat-ud-Dawa. In fact, ISIS has arguably drawn inspiration from a country like Pakistan, which uses non-state actors as a proxy for achieving geopolitical goals.

Locking-up radicalized and unemployed youths in jails only helps to incubate Al-Qaeda in jails. We need to carefully understand radicalisation in order to counter it effectively.
No terror plot would be successful without the governmental use of terror as a tool for achieving its geostrategic goals and similarly, no Countering Violent Extremism strategy will be successful without state responsibility. Naming and shaming is a must!

Politics of Trade policy:

Having joined the trade liberalisation bandwagon and giving up the quotas, why has India failed to take advantage, while the rest of the developing world like China, Bangladesh, Vietnam, Sri Lanka etc. did?
Where have we lost?
  1. India has paid insufficient attention to the value of Trade policy over the years. Eg. In the textiles sector, the enhanced duty drawback scheme, implemented by GoI in 2016 had been suggested way back in 1996. Policy paralysis, lack of will and perhaps lack of full understanding prevented the required steps being taken back then. Had timely steps being taken, India's share of global trade in textiles, clothing would've been much larger.
  2. We need good qualified professionals at the helm of Trade policy decision making, it's too important a matter to be left to generalists.
  3. In addition to trade liberalisation, we need trade-related infrastructure, trade facilitation and a reform of domestic tax and investment regime.
  4. Our private sector must learn and accept the need to compete. Farsightedness and long term planning for investment and technology.
  5. Need to prevent the creeping in of politics into trade and develop a bipartisan consensus on Trade policy due to its direct linkage to national interest and economic prosperity for the country.
  6. India has to become a part of global value chain (GVC), especially so in the present times of dramatic transformation owing to initiatives like BRI, AI, digitalisation of global economy so as to avoid finding ourselves at the fringes of GVCs.

Steps taken by India in the domains of Trade-related infrastructure and ease of doing business-
  • GST
  • DMIC-21st century smart cities for expanding India's manufacturing and services base
  • Make in India - promotion of FDI (Liberalisation of regime), global design & mfg. hub
  • National waterways act, 2016 (first commercial container movement from Kolkata to Varanasi)
  • National bankruptcy act
  • Digital-India pgm- eased G2B interface

Why India is at the fringes of GVCs today?
  • No Indian power figures in the top 20 container ports in the world as per the latest data from World Shipping Council.
  • Whereas there are 10 Chinese ports in the top 20 with Shanghai port at the top in terms of volume shipped.

Sagarmala programme- "P for P" (Ports for Prosperity)
Aims to revitalize the old ports to make them among the finest in the world. ( Port modernization, port connectivity enhancement, coastal community development, port-linked industrialization)

World merchandise trade (USD 16 Trillion) - 2 categories: small basket with 30% value and big basket with 70% value

  • India's exports: 70% in small basket ( shrimps, buffalo meat, small diamond, jewellery, rice etc)
  • Higher end of value chain: electronics, telecom, engineering goods- what India needs to target ( access to latest technology & trade facilitation is the key)

  • Specialised skills and massive effort on R&D
  • Preparation not for tomorrow, but today's fourth IR (AI, Blockchain, robotics, cloud-computing, automation and 3D printing etc)

Today, Indian economy- USD 2.8 Trillion
India's share in global exports- 2% ( merchandise + services)
  • Stagnant since 2013

Our approach to FTAs/PTAs/RTAs and stance in WTO
  • Low utilisation rates in FTAs
  • Not enough opening of services sectors in partner countries

  • Negotiate hard to achieve a deal that defends our national interest!
  • Draw redlines in consultation with stakeholders
  • Take everyone into confidence

Advantages from rcep- 
Part of GVC, access to technology and our products will meet global standards on SPS & TBT.

Our interests are best served by an open, predictable and rules-based MTS ( Multilateral Trading System).
So, our stakes in WTO today are far greater than even Western countries like US)


Carry out far-reaching domestic consultations to reach definitive decisions on what constitutes our fundamental National interest and what can be used as a negotiating leverage to obtain concessions.

Sunday, 6 May 2018

Book review - A life in diplomacy.

A life in diplomacy - M.K.Rasgotra

Mr. M.K.Rasgotra had a career in foreign service spanning 41 years! He joined in 1949 when Nehru was unearthing the basis of India's foreign policy and it's foreign affairs ministry.

Nehru said that peace and freedom are indivisible and that the denial of freedom anywhere MUST endanger freedom elsewhere and lead to conflict & war. On the contrary; though we may witness a small upheaval in the normal functioning of the state of affairs in Bangladesh and India due to denial of freedom to Rohingya minorities in Myanmar but forced withdrawal of freedom from Balochs, Uighurs and many like them, has not endangered freedom anywhere!

Author tells that the primary inception of the so-called Third World was not in Bandung conference but much before that in 1949 when Nehru concerned Asian Relations Conference at New Delhi to condemn the Dutch military's attack to recapture recently liberated Indonesia.
And that Nehru did make efforts on his part to get Tibet the UN Membership but by the time Tibet woke up and realised it's significance, it was too late.

He writes about the stature of the then officials of External Affairs department, how G.S. Bajpai stood up to Nehru and occasionally even made the P.M. to change a decision made on impulse.

According to Mr. Rasgotra, the best part of a young IFS Officer's training lies in her assignments in the first four or five years under caring, interested and sympathetic ambassadors in active missions abroad.

He vividly explains the evolution of IFS for women officers. How Vijay Lakshmi Pandit, who was the then Ambassador to Moscow replied to the Dean of Moscow's diplomatic corps when asked about where would she retire when after the official dinner, men and women separated in two different rooms. She confidently said -" I am an Ambassador and I assert my right to be treated as such. I do not smoke or drink cognac but I shall join the men for political talk".

It was not easy in those days to get the nations respect the femininity of a woman ambassador. A woman speaker in the world's oldest democracy, Britain, was addressed as Mr. Mayor and not Madam Mayor!

He describes the characteristics of a diplomat as per the 19th century American political theorist Benjamin Franklin - the traits that are indispensable in diplomacy include- sleepless tact, immovable calmness and a patience that no folly, no provocations, no blunders can shake!

The author talks about the disappointment of Nehru and his successors with most of their non-career ambassadors. In those days, though the great ambassadors with the likes of  Vijaya Lakshmi Pandit, Krishna Menon, K.M. Pannikar, S.Radhakrishnan elaborated India's distinctive foreign policy on the world stage but reach of them pursued an almost independent foreign policy. Without taking New Delhi in confidence, they conducted their own private negotiations. 

Fast forward to 2018, the concept of lateral entry to MEA needs to be debated and rethought!

He writes that how unequipped were the Americans in general and Secretary of State, John Foster Dulles that he is said to have boosted relations with Pakistan because of his misbelief that Pakistan had Gurkhas- the best fighters in the world!

Nehru's preaching of Asian solidarity to such an extent that he allowed India-US relations to deteriorate due to his differences of opinion on Asian issues like Japanese peace treaty, Korean truce negotiations is judged as a grave policy mistake by India. Were Nehru to apply the policy of Non-alignment to US-China affairs in the same manner as US-USSR power struggle, history would have been different.

US is partly to be blamed for militarisation of Pakistan's thinking and foreign policy which till today Trump, and earlier Obama failed to revert. Washington's policy of arming Pakistan and creating a balance of power between India and Pakistan in 1960s had dangerous consequences for South Asian region, the ripples of which can be felt even today.

The author reveals how Vietnam war could have been prevented had Nehru responded to US President's request to him for his advice as the President himself had miniscule knowledge of Asia and it's affairs.

He writes how our embassies in Moscow and Beijing failed to gauge the extent of strains in China-USSR relations. The starling revelation of Kennedy offering India all technical help to launch nuclear bomb before China did and that G.Parthasarathi, 
India's then Ambassador to China, was responsible for refusal of this American offer, and how Kennedy's well-meaning offer of lifetime was turned down and how we lost the opportunity of deterring China from launching the 1962 war.

How Nepal played and continues to play, time and again, the China card against India and once even tried to persuade Bangladesh to side with them against India by spreading false propaganda.

How after the death of Indira Gandhi, the next PM Rajiv Gandhi was misled into making grave errors in Sri Lanka by reverting India's policy of not interfering politically or militarily in SL and playing into the hands of LTTE. 

As an advice to a diplomat, the author writes that an ambassador who keeps a good table and entertains well- not only officials of the host country but also important opposition leaders, media personalities, distinguished writers, artists and influential civil society figures- gains respect and popularity in the host country.

He makes a valid point whereby he writes that for the wives of diplomats, being a good housekeeper and hostess is a full time job. Governments should find ways to monetarily compensate wives of diplomats for their unavoidable and hitherto unrewarded duties.

Very aptly and briefly, author describes foreign policy as-
  • Framework of principles and practical considerations to safeguard state's security and national interest on a reciprocal basis.
  • Foreign policymaking is a dynamic process, open to adaptation in accord with the changing conditions of the world.
  • That it begins with neighbours, but doesn't remain trapped there. It must transcend the subcontinent's truncated geography.


The opportunity for a PENTAGONAL EQUILIBRIUM among US, Russia, China, Japan and India, if harnessed, would rule out the use of force and make world a safer place to live.
And the primary goal of Indian foreign policy of 21st century should be of forging such an equilibrium through a policy of Engagement With All.

Although India and US are destined to be natural allies, but the author reminds that in cultivating relations with the US, it must always be borne in mind that Washington has a proclivity in a crisis to act primarily and always in its own importance and when a choice between India and Pakistan is forced on it by unforeseen circumstances, then it opts for latter.
According to me, it could be possible that with the emerging closeness between India and US and at the same time, with the growing bitterness of it's relations with Pakistan, this scenario may change; but that change, as of now, appears a bit far in time!

A basic mistake that India did during independence years was to retain British officers in command of the Indian army after independence. Two British generals were in charge of Indian and Pakistani army commands and both were being directed by authorities in London. That is why we failed to clear the Pakistani forces from Gilgit, Baltistan area which is now being explored by China for developing a road link to the Persian gulf!

The author makes some practical recommendations regarding the future of Indian foreign policy, including-
  • Benign but Watchful Engaged with neighbours & a differentiated approach for each.
  • Harnessing the exceptional value of our relations with three significant neighbours: Bhutan, Bangladesh and Myanmar.
  • Lending credence to Act East policy by constructing a broad gauge railway line and/or a six-lane Highway through Siliguri neck to Myanmar, which has the potential to activate the semi-dormant relationship between these two regions.


  • In light of continuing uncertainties in Afghanistan, the author suggests to renew our contacts with our traditional Afghan friends: the Pashtuns, which in my view would greatly help in safeguarding our interests in the region, given the sidelining of Afghanistan-India Strategic Partnership Agreement by the Ghani Government.

Sunday, 31 December 2017

Two thousand and seventeen-
What a year it has been.
Which has brought in life, the much wanted sheen!

From the power corridors of South Block,
To the multilateralist flock!
What a journey it has been!

Life goes on as it never ends,
With the twists and turns and the unnatural bends!
An asset to the nation as a diplomat becomes,
Her life unfolds into uncharted forums!
Far, very far from family and friends,
Into a majestic zone that has no ends!

Back to the childhood days of rushing to school,
With the only absence of mumma’s breakfast tools!

While sitting at the UN in front of your country’s name
Fills you with honour and fame;
But after being there, you realise,
How challenging it’s for diplomacy to materialise!

While in service equations change with designation,
But your faith in work is the only lasting relation!

New country, new language, New culture,
Amidst this newness, I thank all who have left their imprints on my life in 2017- What a year it has been!!


Happy new year :)

Monday, 26 June 2017

Book review - The incredible history of India's Geography

  • ·         The SAN tribe of Kalahari, is probably the oldest surviving population of humans on earth. Genetic study of the members of this tribe reveals that it shows greatest genetic variation of any racial group.
  • ·         The linguistic similarities between Indian and European languages can be explained by genetic similarities among them.  Strains of gene- RLAL, and specifically, a subgroup called- RLALA is found among East Europeans, Indians and some Iranians. These linkages are due to the sharing of a common ancestor.
  • ·         CASTE SYSTEM – is not unique to India. Throughout history, it was present in different versions in Iran, Japan and classical Europe. Remarkable thing about Indian caste system is that it has survived over the years despite the changes in political conditions, technology and religion.
  • ·         The Yezidis, who today live among the Kurds of northern Iraq, eastern Turkey and parts of Armenia, themselves believe that they migrated to middle east from India about 4000 years ago, the time when Harappan civilization disintegrated or perhaps when battle of ten kings took place.
  • ·         Avestan people came to Iran from outside. They called themselves the Aryan people. Persian identity as “Aryans” was so strong that their country came to be known as Land of the Aryans or Iran. As recently as the late 20th century, the Shah of Iran used the title “Aryan-mehr” or the Jewel of the Aryans.
  • ·         India is the only country in the world where lions and tigers coexist.
  • ·         Singapore gets its name from the dual use of the word ‘Singha’-for both lions and tigers-in Rigveda.
  • ·         Communities that are proud of their martial tradition – Sikhs and Rajputs – use Singh (lion) as their surname.
  • ·         Sinhalese – lion people – are the descendents of Prince Vijaya, who was the son of a lion and a human princess.
  • ·         Syrian Christian communities, for long, continued to use Syriac- a dialect of Aramaic language- the language that Jesus Christ used.
  • ·         Sumatra – Island of Gold – also called ‘Suvarnadwipa’.
  • ·         South Vietnam developed as the first Indianized kingdom in SE Asia.
  • ·         Chinese texts tell us of Hindu kingdom of FUNAN, now Cambodia-that flourished in the Mekong delta in 2nd century CE.
  • ·         Funan’s influence evolved into great Hindu-Buddhist kingdoms of Angkor in Cambodia and Champa in Vietnam.
  • ·         In  Sumatra and the Malay peninsula, the Srivijaya kingdom prospered on the trade between India and China.
  • ·         A series of Hindu kingdoms in Java resulted into powerful Mahapit empire in 14th & 15th centuries.
  • ·         The national languages of both Malaysia and Indonesia are called ‘BAHASA’, derived from the Sanskrit word ‘bhasha’.
  • ·         Indian cultural influence extends all the way to Korea. According to Samguk Yusa, Princess Huh Hwang-ok of Ayodhya sailed to Korea to marry King Suro in 4th century CE. Their sons founded Korea’s earliest dynasty.
  • ·         The Javanese  perform the Ramayana in their style.
  • ·         The festival of Kartik Purnima, continues to be celebrated on the day when sea merchants set sail for SE Asia.
  • ·         In Cuttack, Bali yatra takes place, marking the departure of merchant fleet for the island of Bali.
  • ·         Cholas established direct trade links with Chinese and exchanged trade delegations in early 11th century. A large Indian merchant community had established itself in Guangzhou and there were even three Hindu temples functioning there.
  • ·         Nalanda university received strong financial support from Srivijaya kings of Malaya peninsula.
  • ·         Arabs spoke of Iraqi port of Basra as ‘belonging to al-Hind’ as Indian goods and merchants dominated this market. Steel sword was one of the important items of export.
  • ·         Kerala, even today has a number of Arab settlers. Moplahs form a quarter of state’s population. Gujarat became home to Parsis.
  • ·         Around late 7th century, a group of people from Central India travelled West, across the Middle East, to Europe. Today, we know them as Gypsies or the Roma. Language, culture and now genetic studies have indicated strong links between the Roma and India.
  • ·         In 1971, at the World Romani Conference, the Roma adopted a blue and green flag for their nomadic nation, with a wheel at the centre – the symbol of Chakravartin.
  • ·         The shakti tradition associated with the worship of Goddess Durga has spread beyond India in South and SE Asia, including Jaffna in Sri Lanka, Prambanan temple complex in central java.
  • ·         Around 17th century, the caste system in India became more rigid, Sanskrit literature became possessed with ’purity’. There seems to have been a shift in India’s attitude towards risk-taking and innovation- closing of minds. Scientific progress came to a halt as people began focusing on learned knowledge rather than experimenting.
  • ·         Hindu temples built by Chams are still scattered across Vietnam- with a few used by tiny Balamon Cham community that continues to practice Hinduism.
  • ·         SE Asia was predominantly influenced by Hinduism, but it became steadily Islamized under the strategy of Chinese admiral Zheng He. Majahapit empire of Java was the most powerful Hindu empire. Zheng He developed a strategy to neutralize the Majahapit. The Chinese encouraged the Melakkans (new kingdom of Melakka formed by a Srivijaya king) to convert to Islam. Possibly, the Chinese wanted to reduce the risk of Indians once again influencing the region.
But the Chinese domination of seas, came to a sudden end. The mandarin officials decided that the voyages were too expensive and not worth it. Like India, China also closed its mind. Technological superiority could not save them from change in attitude.


  •               The Marathas were the only Indians who had developed some map-making ability.
  • ·         There was a sizeable population of lions in North India in early 1800s. William Frazer, a British Indian civil servant, is supposed to have shot eighty-four lions in 1820s and he took great pride in having been personally responsible for the extinction of species in Haryana.
  • ·         There are remains of a large Indian trading post in faraway Azerbaijan. Built in 17th and 18th century, the Ateshgah of Baku includes the remains of a Hindu temple.
  • ·         A place in Mauritius where half a million Indian workers landed, is called ‘AAPRAVASI GHAT’ or Immigration depot and is now a UNESCO world heritage site.
  • ·         Tamil Chettiar community established a network in Burma, Malaya, Singapore and even French – controlled Vietnam.
  • ·         Hong Kong, has a number of successful Sindhi business families.

Book review - death of a nation and future of Arab revolution

The death of the nation and the future of Arab Revolution

It is one of the best books detailing the root causes behind the conflict in Middle East.
In the first Chapter, author Vijay Prashad explains how during the times of Arab Spring, Saudi Arabia snuffed its disgruntled population with jail sentences to instill fear in them so that they never rise in protest against the kingdom. Saudi regime entered Bahrain to crush its Pearl Monument encampment. The biggest blow to Arab Nationalism came not directly from either the West or Saudi Arabia, but from the defeat of Arab armies in the 1967 “Battle of Destiny” against Israel. It was this defeat that broke the spirit of Arab possibilities.
 While the political Islam had a growth spurt in 1980s, but in Syria, it was severely repressed. An ill-fated attempt at political power, which was driven by gun, in the 1970s ended for the Syrian Brotherhood in the ash-heap of Hama. The Syrian Brotherhood was the only Muslim Brotherhood group of any capacity in West Asia. It was crushed by 1982 and never recovered after that.
The phenomenon of regime change is easier to give effect, but on the ground, implementation of this new regime is a complex process. The overthrow of autocratic Government occurs in a short term, the consolidation of new regime takes place in medium term, and then the economic and cultural changes required to setup a new dispensation take place in long term. The Arab Spring, was the first phase of short term. The region poised to enter the medium phase, with the fights to establish the new Governmental authority that would be loyal to the spirit of Arab Spring, took place. Now, the ledger is unbalanced. History oscillates between a return to the time before 2010 and to the edge of the next moment.
The author aptly asks, “if the old regimes seemed incapable of solving the problems of the present, what political forces today have answers to current challenges?”

Origin of Hezbollah:
Iraqi cleric Al-Sadr studied Marxism and Communism as did many others Islamist thinkers.  Al-Sadr’s movement drew from Bolshevism and Islamic socialism. Adoption of socialism’s idioms allowed this branch of political Islam neither reactionary nor lethargic. Out of these initiatives grew Hezbollah in Lebanon and Sadr movement in Iraq.
Arab Nationalism might have developed alliances with communism as both had taken antagonistic position against imperialism and colonialism. But this was not to be. The communists endangered the status quo as they rose in struggles against the tendency of Arab nationalists to favor domestic bourgeoisie over the peasants and workers.
Arab communists felt compelled to follow the Soviet Union’s recognition of Israel in 1948 cutting them off from the greater mood of anger at the Palestinian naqba. This association undermined the principled critique of Arab nationalism by the communists.
The combination of Arab Nationalism and communism threatened the sultans of Saudi Arabia and their US backers. In 1962, the Saudi regime created the World Muslim league as they felt that Islam formed a significant bulwark against communism.

Saudi intelligence and the military forces provoked uprisings in Oman and in Yemen to push petty claims of land, and get rid of communists in both these nations. OIC was created in 1969 to provide counterweight to NAM.

Birth of 9/11
Bin Laden formed al-Qaeda in 1989 and strengthened it over time. Worried that Saudi monarch would allow US troops to eject Saddam Hussein’s army, Bin Laden recommended that the al-Qaeda men do this task. On the refusal of Saudi king, Bin Laden set onto a course of permanent war against both the near army (Arab leaders) and the far enemy (US). Thus, 9/11 was born in that refusal.
First aerial bombardment in world history – in 1911, when Italians bombed Libya, a hundred years later, West retuned for a sequel in Libya.

Syrian war
The author quotes a senior Kurdish commander of YPG as saying that Turkey was to Syria, what Pakistan was to Afghanistan. Like Pakistan, Turkey allowed itself to become a base for foreign extremists eager to go across the border and destabilize it’s neighbor. Trucks with World Food Org. logos were seen to be carrying ISIS fighters into Syria. Even Qatari charities sent aid and assistance to ISIS controlled areas in Syria.

Yemen crisis

The conflict in Yemen-with no outcome in sight-will possibly draw ordinary Yemeni Sunnis to consider Al-Qaeda-in-Arabian-Peninsula a positive influence on the country. This is the danger of sectarian wars that have no endgame. They will not end with a utopian outcome. They can end only where life becomes evil. 

My stint at FSI

Coming through the mighty rivers gushing down the snow clad mountains,
All the way to the plains of Delhi;
We bid adieu to Mussoorie nights,
And embraced FSI Heights!

From sharing rooms devoid of space,
To 1BHK as if we moved into vastness of outer space,
Into the deep end of swimming pool,
Where every other person tried to be cool!

Domestic policy, foreign policy,
Hospitality module,finance module,
But the lasting influence would be of,
Ambassador Talmiz Ahmad's Gulf module!

Then came the high point of Bharat Darshan,
An immersion of joy, bonds and exploration;
Bharat- A mosaic of culture and tradition,
That we wish to promote with precision!

Lowest point was the tedious task of filling forms,
With the clearing of TA Bills blowing horns;
Wish I could have surpassed probation,
And happily escaped this situation!

From Myanmar to Srilanka,
Don't know whether it was promotion or demotion,
But the attachment was full of emotion!
From floating Parliament to the sight of majestic blue whales,
When it comes to DCM's dinner tales,
Indian mission in Srilanka hails!

With the aim of connecting my state with the outside world,
I landed in Haryana,where it unfurled,
That Chandigarh has a UNESCO world heritage site,
An instant connect I found, to my delight!

Then suddenly FSI turned into LBSNAA, into a mission mode,
A week full of reports, memos, thesis and their defence;
That foreign service had nothing to do with sports,
Sports meet busted all the myths of such sorts!

The final attachment provided an exposure to armed forces,
Without whose valour, India would have lost discourses;
From ambush laying to Bofors and INSAS shooting,
Army's warmth and hospitality deserves hooting!
After visiting Sukhois and submarines,
Our journey through glimpses of Bharat, halts to reconvene!

Stint at FSI that began as the biggest batch,
Comes to an end with the catch,
That the bonding will remain unmatched- FOREVER!!